ROTW #1 - Yes, but no

It IS subjective after all

Until we pick up some readership, I’ll use my sleuthing to find some interesting rejected photos…(and probably it’s not ‘weekly’…)

”Ok for me”

Have a gander at this exchange on the Jetphotos forum.

Here’s a delightful example of how the pre-screening forum can even it get it wrong. Nothing like a senior screener saying “it’s okay” and then the original poster saying it was rejected in the end. Makes the algorithm we use here pretty decent doesn’t it? Those fallible meat based screeners.

Sidebar: to remain fair to the crew, there is an unofficial FAQ:

18. A pre-screening advice is not a 100% Guarantee of the final result! Sometimes there can be differences.

Analysis

For reference, here’s a histogram of the image in question, if that even means anything.

Not really sure much more can be done…If we must, perhaps there’s a concern about a ‘flat-spot’ in the histogram on the right side? It is difficult to know since no further elaborations provided in the thread. We don’t screen histograms as they say(??) so go to the original link to see the full picture.

Have any thoughts? DM us on Instagram, If you’re not Gen-Z, you can do email too I guess